X

Why a Science Channel documentary on Ram Sethu has got Smriti Irani and co excited

 "There are Hindu legends that the God Rama placed a bridge here connecting India and Sri Lanka," says a geologist in the video clip.

A Science Channel documentary clip on Ram Sethu or Adam’s bridge, touted to have connected India with Sri Lanka in the past, has gone viral with the likes of Subramanian Swamy and Smriti Irani tweeting about it. The video apparently vindicates the stand of many right-wing ideologues that the bridge was indeed built by Lord Rama.

In a documentary, titled “What on Earth: A land bridge”, a group of oceanologists and archaeologists are seen analysing the satellite images of the bridge that have stones sitting on top of sand bars. They conclude that while the stones are 7,000 years old, the sand on which it is sitting is only 4,000-year-old. Following this observation, they conclude that the discrepancy in the age of the sand and the stone proves that the stone bridge must have been built by human beings. The 2-minute clip ends with one of the experts referring to an ancient Hindu text, that talks about Rama’s existence about 5,000 years ago.  “There are Hindu legends that the God Rama placed a bridge here, connecting India and Sri Lanka,” says a geologist named Dr Alan Lester, Geologist. Another expert adds that building such a bridge at that point of time in history would have been a “super human achievement”.

The clip has now gone viral.

Are the ancient Hindu myths of a land bridge connecting India and Sri Lanka true? Scientific analysis suggests they are. #WhatonEarth pic.twitter.com/EKcoGzlEET

— Science Channel (@ScienceChannel) December 11, 2017

Many are tweeting it as a counter to the previous government, led by Congress, whose official stand was that Valmiki Ramayana and Ramcharitmanas cannot be treated as historical records of Ram’s existence.  The UPA government had said this to the Supreme Court that was hearing a case on the controversial Sethusamudran project.

Subramanian Swamy was one of the first to take note of the video on Twitter.

Going to visit the site soon

— Subramanian Swamy (@Swamy39) December 12, 2017

Later, Information and Broadcasting Minister Smriti Irani also tweeted it with the caption “Jai Shri Ram”

जय श्री राम https://t.co/M85KFnyZIY

— Smriti Z Irani (@smritiirani) December 11, 2017

Here are some other reactions from tweeples.

But in 2007 the then Government there is no historical proof of Maryada Purshottam Shri Ram, in an affidavit in the Supreme Court https://t.co/LFLFKU4Yuk And in connection with the same Ram Sethu…

जय श्री राम 🙂 https://t.co/UUYnbk0en3

— GAURAV C SAWANT (@gauravcsawant) December 12, 2017

Pls come here to go through and make our land as herritage place. And name that bridge as Ram sethu bridge officially. Google showed them as Adam’s bridge https://t.co/mNhQv3jThv

— கபாலி (@proudhindu009) December 12, 2017

Video Evidence of Bridge Construction. Solved. pic.twitter.com/XycLzoMYfq

— vikas(Викас) (@vikasF22) December 11, 2017

The problem with westerners is that they believe anything excelling them in history is either alien or myth.No dude it’s not,our every belief is based on science,Just wait and let science unravel the mysteries of Sanatan Dharma.Just like saraswati-sindhu civilisation,

— Aman Kashyap (@AmanKashyap89) December 12, 2017

Ram Sethu is man made, So did Ram Mandir exist.

Only “Secular “ lobby denied it for own purposes. Reclaim our Glorious past & it’s achievements https://t.co/3JHSSfF2xT

— Ishkaran Singh Bhandari (@Ish_Bhandari) December 12, 2017

Thank you for your analysis! #whatonearth. Also, want to remind you that #RamSethu was built by #LordRam with the help of Hanuman’s Vanar Sena to free his wife Sita from the captivity of ‘demon king’ Ravana. Existence of #Ram is not a myth, it is our reality! #Jaishreeram https://t.co/mCRWLQAeND

— Monika (@mera_apnabharat) December 12, 2017

It is now Scientifically proved that “Ram Sethu is man made, So did Ram Mandir exist” Mandir ohi banega. Jai Sri Ram. https://t.co/qqamncyssD

— Yogi Aashish (@ThinkZingThing) December 12, 2017

Not just that #RamSethu exist. It is clear Shoal (sandbars) could be natural but whatever is sitting on it is not. Proves it is Man-made (and not natural) Exactly what Dr @Swamy39 said all along. #MuKa Lord Rama was beyond Engineering. https://t.co/aJciXRFO7c

— Suresh N (@surnell) December 11, 2017

Here’s a transcript of the 2-minute long video clip:

A NASA satellite passes over the shallow waters of the Indian ocean. It sends back images of largely submerged objects. Investigators find that the line of rocks is over 30 miles long. The rocks are in an area mentioned in an ancient Hindu poem that refers to a magic bridge. The stones are sitting on something that oceanographer call shoar or a sand bar. The sand bar may be natural.

There are stones that have been brought from afar and set on top. How these stones got here is a mystery. When geologists date the stones the mystery deepens. Scientific analysis reveal that rocks are 7000 years old but are sitting on top of sand that are only 4000 year old. This suggest that the structure was built by humans. Some scholars believe that the Hindu text refer to a time 5000 year ago. At this point of time building such a bridge would be super human achievement.

While the BJP has always maintained that the bridge has religious sentiments attached to it, in 2004, the UPA had mooted the Sethusamudram Shipping Canal Project (SSCP) project that aimed at linking the east and west coasts of India without the need to go around Sri Lanka. According to a Wire report, the construction of the project required “dredging (or even blasting) of the 20-km-long coral-reef platform known as ‘Adam’s Bridge’ or ‘Ram Sethu’”. In 2007, justifying  the construction, the UPA government had told the Supreme Court,

“Valmiki Ramayana and Ramcharitmanas admittedly form an important part of ancient Indian literature, but these cannot be said to be historical records to incontrovertibly prove the existence of the characters and occurrences of events depicted therein.”

The Narendra Modi government has said that any re-alignment or damage to the sethu wouldn’t be approved. Several environmentalists have also red-flagged the project.